Background

Here are the results from a South Atlantic MSE exercise testing the behavior of model-based versus empirical MPs for black sea bass (BSB), vermilion snapper (VS), and red porgy (RP) using the openMSE software (Blue Matter Science).

VS Results

Median Trajectory Plots

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for model MPs

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for model MPs

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for empirical MPs

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for empirical MPs

Median SSB / static SSBMSY trajectories

Median SSB / static SSBMSY trajectories

Median catch trajectories

Median catch trajectories

Biomass Performance Metrics

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

Fishing mortality metrics

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

Yield metrics

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

Cumulative Performance Metrics

MP performance across OMs

MP performance across OMs

Trade off plots

MP performance across OMs

MP performance across OMs

Worm plots

## $seed
## [1] 8675309
## 
## $iters
## [1] 212 107 202  11 192  77 147 169  78
MP performance across OMs

MP performance across OMs

## $seed
## [1] 8675309
## 
## $iters
## [1] 212 107 202  11 192
## $seed
## [1] 8675309
## 
## $iters
## [1] 212 107 202  11 192
## $seed
## [1] 8675309
## 
## $iters
## [1] 212 107 202  11 192
MP performance across OMs

MP performance across OMs

BSB Results

Median Trajectory Plots

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for model MPs

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for model MPs

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for empirical MPs

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for empirical MPs

Median SSB / static SSBMSY trajectories

Median SSB / static SSBMSY trajectories

Median catch trajectories

Median catch trajectories

Biomass Performance Metrics

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

Fishing mortality metrics

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

Yield metrics

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

Cumulative Performance Metrics

MP performance across OMs

MP performance across OMs

Trade off plots

MP performance across OMs

MP performance across OMs

Worm plots

## $seed
## [1] 8675309
## 
## $iters
## [1] 212 107 202  11 192  77 147 169  78
MP performance across OMs

MP performance across OMs

## $seed
## [1] 8675309
## 
## $iters
## [1] 212 107 202  11 192
## $seed
## [1] 8675309
## 
## $iters
## [1] 212 107 202  11 192
## $seed
## [1] 8675309
## 
## $iters
## [1] 212 107 202  11 192
MP performance across OMs

MP performance across OMs

RP Results

Median Trajectory Plots

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for model MPs

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for model MPs

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for empirical MPs

Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for empirical MPs

Median SSB / static SSBMSY trajectories

Median SSB / static SSBMSY trajectories

Median catch trajectories

Median catch trajectories

Biomass Performance Metrics

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

OM-specific MP biomass performance

Fishing mortality metrics

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance

Yield metrics

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

OM-specific MP yield performance

Cumulative Performance Metrics

MP performance across OMs

MP performance across OMs

Trade off plots

MP performance across OMs

MP performance across OMs

Worm plots

## $seed
## [1] 8675309
## 
## $iters
## [1] 212 107 202  11 192  77 147 169  78
MP performance across OMs

MP performance across OMs

## $seed
## [1] 8675309
## 
## $iters
## [1] 212 107 202  11 192
## $seed
## [1] 8675309
## 
## $iters
## [1] 212 107 202  11 192
## $seed
## [1] 8675309
## 
## $iters
## [1] 212 107 202  11 192
MP performance across OMs

MP performance across OMs